用户名:  密码:   
栏目导航 — 美国华裔教授专家网最新消息社区报道
关键字  范围   
加州大学(UC)将取消高校入学考试 SAT & ACT (附中、英文报道)
来源:洛杉矶时报 | 2020/9/2 9:06:35 | 浏览:219 | 评论:0

UC must immediately drop use of the SAT and ACT for admissions and scholarships, judge rules

加州大学(UC)将取消高校入学考试 SAT & ACT (附中、英文报道)
The University of California must immediately suspend use of SAT or ACT test scores for admission and scholarship decisions, an Alameda County Superior Court judge has ruled.
(Mario Tama / Getty Images)

The University of California must immediately suspend all use of SAT and ACT test scores for admission and scholarship decisions under a preliminary injunction issued by an Alameda County Superior Court judge.

The ruling came in a lawsuit asserting that the use of standardized test scores is broadly biased — and particularly detrimental to students with disabilities who seek to take the test during the coronavirus crisis.

Superior Court Judge Brad Seligman said in his Monday ruling that plaintiffs had shown sufficient cause to stop the tests for now because applicants with disabilities had virtually no access to test-taking sites or legally required accommodations during the COVID-19 pandemic.

“The barriers faced by students with disabilities have been greatly exacerbated by the COVID-19 epidemic, which has disrupted test-taking locations, closed schools and limited access to school counselors,” Seligman wrote.

Seligman added that little data existed to show whether the tests were even valid or reliable indicators of their future college performance. He set a case management conference for Sept. 29.

The injunction on the use of SAT and ACT results will affect all California applicants to the UC system.

“The SAT and ACT are dead and gone as far as the UC system is concerned,” said Mark Rosenbaum, a Los Angeles attorney who helped file the lawsuit as director of Public Counsel’s Opportunity Under Law project. The “historic decision puts an end to racist tests that deprived countless California students of color, students with disabilities, and students from low-income families of a fair shot at admissions to the UC system.”

Rosenbaum said he and his team targeted only the UC system to efficiently manage the case but that the court’s reasoning should apply to all colleges and universities, both public and private, across the country.

Learn more about the versatile Kia Sportage.

“If other universities don’t follow, we’ll come after them as well,” he said, adding that he would be conferring with civil and disability rights advocates in other states.

In a statement Tuesday, UC said it “respectfully disagrees” with the court decision and was evaluating whether it would pursue further legal actions.

“An injunction may interfere with the university’s efforts to implement an appropriate and comprehensive admissions policies and its ability to attract and enroll students of diverse backgrounds and experiences,” the statement said.

SAT officials did not immediately respond to requests for comment but have long argued that their tests are not discriminatory and provide a uniform and useful yardstick to assess applicants from different schools and states.

ACT officials said they offered accommodations to students with disabilities and are committed to “ensuring access to our assessment’ for them “despite the difficulties that COVID-19 has presented globally.”

Earlier this year, the UC Board of Regents unanimously voted to phase out standardized test scores in admissions decisions after concluding that the tests were unacceptably biased based on race, income and parent education level and did not provide useful information about how students would fare in college. Regents voted to make the tests optional this year and next, then phase them out, but would still allow them to be used for scholarship decisions. Regents also gave campuses the flexibility to choose to drop them immediately rather than continue using them on an optional basis until 2022.

UC Berkeley, UC Irvine and UC Santa Cruz already have decided to drop the SAT and ACT testing requirements altogether. Most of the system’s five other undergraduate campuses, including UCLA, had planned to consider the scores for applicants who chose to submit them. UC campuses will begin accepting applications for admission to the 2021-22 academic year on Nov. 1.

“University admissions officials and faculty are best positioned to determine appropriate admissions decisions and procedures, taking into account the individual needs and priorities of a particular campus,” the UC statement said.

The lawsuit was brought by several high school students and nonprofits, including Community Coalition, Dolores Huerta Foundation, College Seekers, Chinese for Affirmative Action, College Access and Little Manila Rising. One plaintiff, identified only as Gary W., was described in the ruling as a recent high school graduate with learning disabilities who had completed all UC admission prerequisites(which include several college-prep courses). But the student faced what the ruling called “formidable barriers” to taking the SAT and ultimately could not do so, prompting his decision to not apply for UC admission this year.

Some accommodations, such as Braille and large-print exams, 100% extended time for tests and computers for those who cannot hand write essays, are only available at high school testing centers, but those have been closed during the coronavirus crisis, said Abigail Graber, an attorney with Brown, Goldstein & Levy, a Baltimore law firm representing the plaintiffs. She added that students also have been unable to obtain needed documentation of their disabilities because they can’t meet with high school counselors and psychologists for evaluations during the pandemic.

In its own filing, the university argued that campuses should have the flexibility to use optional testing as allowed this year and next so all applicants can showcase their strengths — which could be test scores for some disadvantaged students, including those with disabilities. Applicants who perform well on standardized tests, for instance, could use their scores to offset lower grades or completion of fewer honors or AP courses.

UC officials also argued that a ruling was premature because the application window for fall 2021 won’t open until November and most campuses have not finalized their admissions process yet. Therefore, UC argued, no applicant has yet demonstrated any harm suffered.

Seligman, however, rejected those assertions. He agreed with UC that no data yet exists that show students with disabilities have been harmed. But he noted that several campuses have indicated they plan to give all applicants a first review based on factors other than test scores, then provide a second review with test scores for those who have them. Most if not all students with disabilities would be denied the benefit of the second review, he said, since the chances of being able to take the SAT or ACT with or without accommodations during the pandemic are “almost nil.”

“In short, applicants with disabilities are denied meaningful access to the ‘aid, benefit or service’ that test-takers have,” Seligman wrote. “They are denied a potential second chance at admission.”




洛杉矶时报今天的大标题是:加州大学必须立即停止使用SAT或ACT成绩来进行大学录取和奖学金决定“UC must immediately drop use of the SAT and ACT for admissions and scholarships, judge rules“。

加州大学(UC)将取消高校入学考试 SAT & ACT (附中、英文报道)




高等法院法官布拉德·塞利格曼(Brad Seligman)在周一的裁决中说,原告已经有足够的理由暂时停止这类标化考试,因为在COVID-19大流行期间,残疾申请人实际上根本无法进入考试地点或达到法律上规定的条件。

塞利格曼写道:“ COVID-19流行病极大地加剧了残疾学生所面临的障碍,这种流行扰乱了参加考试的地点,封闭的学校以及获得学校辅导员的机会,”塞利格曼补充说,几乎没有数据可以证明这些测试甚至是其未来大学表现的有效或可靠指标。


发起诉讼的洛杉矶律师马克·罗森鲍姆(Mark Rosenbaum)说:“就UC系统而言,SAT和ACT早已一去不复返了”,这位律师作为一个“法律机会的公共法律顾问”项目的主任发起诉讼。 他说“这是历史性的判决,终结了种族主义考试,这类(SAT ACT标化)种族考试剥夺了无数加州有色,残障和低收入家庭学生入读UC系统的机会。




就在不久之前,加州大学伯克利分校,加州大学欧文分校和加州圣克鲁斯分校已经决定完全放弃SAT和ACT考试要求,但根据法官周一做出的该裁定,其他的学校 加州大学洛杉矶分校和该系统的其他五个本科校园已计划考虑选择提交分数的申请人的分数。UC校园将于11月1日开始接受2021-22学年的入学申请。

加利福尼亚大学(University of California),简称加州大学,是位于美国加利福尼亚州的一个由10所公立大学组成的大学行政系统,是世界上最具影响力的公立大学系统,也是最大的大学联邦体,其旗下大学在各项学术指标和排名中均名列前茅,  被誉为“公立高等教育的典范”。包括加大伯克利分校(UC Berkeley)、加大洛杉矶分校(UCLA)、加大圣地亚哥分校(UCSD)、加大旧金山分校(UCSF)、加大圣塔芭芭拉分校(UCSB)、加大尔湾分校(UCI)、加大戴维斯分校(UCD)、加大圣克鲁兹分校(UCSC)、加大河滨分校(UCR)、加大美熹德分校(UCM)。

一天之内,3名国际顶尖学者归国,分别全职加盟北大、浙大、南大 2020-09-27 [684]
华人圈震怒!被FBI逮捕的中国学者竟然是被自己的华人导师出卖 2020-09-26 [1120]
政府对大学的政治镇压,引发美国学界对华裔人才外流的担忧 2020-09-15 [144]
美国多所大学复课后被员工起诉,因数以千计学生与职工检出新冠阳性 2020-09-13 [174]
《USNews》最新美国大学排名公布! 2020-09-13 [211]
AI视觉领域泰斗级学者、UCLA教授朱松纯将回国任教清华 2020-09-13 [378]
印度裔“教授”的神操作!办假顶会欺骗欧美学术精英…… 2020-09-06 [170]
加州拟修法:与未成年人性交 或可不登记为性罪犯 2020-09-05 [151]
耶鲁校长2020开学演讲:慈悯之心与合作之道,才是改变世界的“正解” 2020-09-01 [631]
哈佛75年研究成果:孩子越长越笨多半有6种坏习惯 2020-08-28 [203]
:浙江财经大学国际青年学者论坛的邀请函 (10/31-11/1) :南宁职业技术学院2019年招聘公告 :美国加大审查范围 北大多名美国留学生遭联邦调查局质询 :天安门广场喜迎“十一”花团锦簇的美丽景象 :Daily Journal董事会主席芒格:中国的水还行, 聪明人已经趟进去了 陈沉:FDA称雷尼替丁存在致癌物 Sandoz药物销售被叫停 :印裔人才在美碾压华裔:我们可以从印度教育中学到什么? :假如美国大学们都有一句诚实的Slogan
注意: 留言内容不要超过4000字,否则会被截断。
未 审 核:  是
Copyright © 2020 ScholarsUpdate.com. All Rights Reserved.